Bad stats: 5/10
Role in team success: 8/10
Expectations: 9/10
Overall Bust Index: 22/30
Though he lands on the list of Heisman busts, Howard is one of the most iconic winners in the award's history. His most memorable moment came against Ohio State in 1991, when he returned a punt 82 yards for a touchdown, striking the "Heisman pose" in the end zone.
Though he became one of the best return men in NFL history — his 99-yard kickoff return in Super Bowl XXXI earned him the game's MVP award — Howard lands on this list due to his pedestrian numbers as a wide receiver. He caught just 123 passes during his nine-year career for 1,597 yards and seven touchdowns. The Redskins were probably hoping for more than just a return specialist when they took Howard with No. 4 overall pick in the 1992 draft.
