Bad stats: 2/10
Role in team success: 4/10
Expectations: 10/10
Overall Bust Index: 16/30
Testaverde threw for 2,557 yards and 26 touchdowns in 1986, becoming Miami's first Heisman winner. He was taken with the No. 1 overall pick in the 1987 draft and played a remarkable 21 seasons in the NFL, with two Pro Bowl appearances.
But Testaverde's career was one of a journeyman — he played for seven different teams, and never stayed in one place for more than six seasons. He made three playoff appearances as a starter — one with the Browns and two with the Jets — with two wins. Though most would consider a career spanning three different decades a resounding success, the fact that he was unable to stick with one franchise qualifies him (just barely) as a Heisman bust.
