There was a time when Prince Andrew had it all: A decorated war hero, a playboy prince, an international ambassador for the British brand, living the life of privilege. But those days seem long gone. Instead, the Duke of York -- who is ninth in line to the British throne -- is now being sued for alleged sexual abuse.
Federal court documents filed Monday reveal that a lawsuit was filed by Virginia Roberts Giuffre, an alleged victim of sex offender and disgraced financier Jeffrey Epstein. Giuffre has previously said publicly that she was forced to perform sex acts with Britain's Prince Andrew, telling the BBC in 2019 that she was trafficked by Epstein and forced to have sex with his friends, including the Duke of York, when she was underage.
Andrew has repeatedly denied Giuffre's allegations. But his association with Epstein has cast a dark shadow over him.
Facing pressure from the public, the Prince stepped back from royal duties in the wake of a 2019 interview he gave the BBC in which he was widely considered to have damaged his own credibility. He rarely appears in public. When his elder daughter, Princess Beatrice, married last year, he wasn't shown in any of the four official photographs released.
Buckingham Palace has previously denied Giuffre's allegations in a 2019 statement to CNN, saying "It is emphatically denied that The Duke of York had any form of sexual contact or relationship with Virginia Roberts. Any claim to the contrary is false and without foundation."
On Tuesday, a representative for the duke's legal team declined to comment. Buckingham Palace also declined to comment.
Alexâ McCready, the head of Reputation & Privacy at Vardags, a law firm specializing in handling cases of high-profile clients, said the Prince isn't facing the risk of being extradited, because the lawsuit is a civil matter.
"If he fails to cooperate he will face a default judgment, significant damages and a reputation further in tatters. Another option, often preferred in these high profile cases, is an out of court settlement," she said.
Gerhard Kemp, a law professor at the University of Derby in the UK, said the complaint by Giuffre is unlikely to change the duke's situation dramatically, since it doesn't seem to include substantial new information beyond what has already been alleged.
The ongoing criminal case against Ghislaine Maxwell, a British socialite and former girlfriend of Epstein, could cause a bigger headache for the Prince, Kemp said.
"The gamechanger will be if the criminal case against Maxwell is going to yield significant evidence implicating the Duke of York, which in turn may alter the nature of proceedings in the US from the current civil case to a possible criminal case against the Duke," he told CNN in an email.
Maxwell has been charged with conspiracy and sex trafficking, conspiracy and enticing minors to travel to engage in illegal sex acts, and the transportation of minors to engage in criminal sexual activity for allegedly grooming, recruiting and abusing underage girls from 1994 to 1997. She has pleaded not guilty.
US authorities have previously accused Andrew of not cooperating with attempts to interview him as part of the investigation into the alleged sex trafficking ring âEpstein and Maxwell are suspected of operating.
Then-US Attorney for the Southern District of New York Geoffrey Berman said in January 2020 that Andrew had not cooperated with attempts to interview him about Epstein, despite saying he would. "To date Prince Andrew has provided zero cooperation," Berman said at the time.
Federal prosecutors requested an interview in June 2020 with Prince Andrew as part of its investigation into the alleged sex trafficking ring once operated by Epstein, a source told CNN at the time.
But there is little else they can do. Unless the Prince himself becomes a target of criminal investigation, their options are limited.
"In the absence of a formal criminal complaint in the US against the Duke of York, my expectation is that we will continue to see the status quo ... requests by the US authorities for the duke/his legal team to provide voluntary co-operation and the duke/his legal team will continue to say they are willing to co-operate, an assertion that seems to be somewhat disputed by the US authorities," Kemp said.
Prince Andrew himself discussed the allegations in a November 2019 BBC interview that sparked near-universal condemnation in the British press and on social media.
He told BBC Newsnight's Emily Maitlis he had seen nothing that struck him as suspicious when he was around Epstein, who died by suicide in August 2019 while awaiting trial on federal charges that he sexually abused underage girls and ran a sex trafficking ring. Epstein had pleaded not guilty.
'Spare heir'
Andrew, whose royal title is His Royal Highness The Duke of York, is the second son of Queen Elizabeth II and a brother of Prince Charles.
Originally second in line to the throne, he became number three when Prince William was born, and has slipped lower following subsequent royal births. He is now number nine in the line of succession.
Being the "spare heir" is a notoriously tricky role to fill. Over the course of his lifetime, Andrew has seen his chances of acceding to the throne diminish -- yet he still faces all the scrutiny and expectations that come with being a royal.
Like other "spares," notably the Queen's sister, the late Princess Margaret, and more recently Prince Harry, Andrew was at times seen as the "party royal."
His colorful past is perhaps best illustrated by the number of nicknames UK tabloids have come up with for the prince over the years, from "Randy Andy" to "Airmiles Andy."
British tabloids have often referred to the duke as the Queen's favorite child. The claim seems to be rooted in the fact that the Queen was able to spend more time with him and his younger brother Prince Edward, the Earl of Wessex, during their early childhood compared to her two elder children Prince Charles and Princess Anne, who were born just before she ascended to the throne.
Unlike his older brother Charles, Andrew didn't go to university. Instead, he joined the Royal Navy. A few years later, he was sailing across the Atlantic on a mission to retake the Falkland Islands from Argentina. He returned a hero -- and a darling of the nation.
Enter Sarah Ferguson.
The prince and Ferguson, known as "Fergie," were the ultimate "It" couple of the late 1980s. Their wedding drew a TV audience of hundreds of millions. Tens of thousands of people lined the streets on the day, an event the New York Times described as "Fergie fever."
The scandalous years
Ferguson was said to bring a breath of fresh air to the royal family. But the honeymoon was soon over. Andrew and Ferguson separated in 1992 and divorced in 1996, following a number of scandals. However, the two maintain a close relationship -- much to the amusement of UK tabloids.
After leaving active military service in 2001, the prince became a "full-time royal," carving out a role for himself as a champion of British business. He became the United Kingdom's special representative for international trade and investment, traveling the world selling the British brand.
That career came to an abrupt end a few months after he was photographed with Epstein in Central Park in 2010. At that time Epstein was a registered sex offender who had served 13 months in prison on prostitution-related charges.
The Epstein link
Andrew was one of the many high-profile, influential men Epstein had associated with. The prince said he met Epstein in 1999 and "saw him infrequently and probably no more than only once or twice a year." He also admitted to having stayed at "a number of his [Epstein's] residences."
The prince has always claimed he never suspected the kind of behavior that Epstein was convicted, and again later, accused of. But that claim is problematic given he associated with Epstein even after his 2008 plea deal, in which he pleaded guilty to two state prostitution charges.
While Andrew insists he never witnessed or suspected the behavior that led to Epstein's arrest, he has admitted it was "a mistake and an error" to see the disgraced financier in 2010.
***
Photos: Prince Andrew through the years
Britain's Royal family
Updated
Britain's Royal family sits on blanket on the grounds of Balmoral Castle, Scotland, Sept. 8, 1960, during current holiday. Prince Andrew, in lap of his father, Prince Philip, reaches for trinket presented by his mother, Queen Elizabeth II, Princess Anne and Prince Charles try to catch the baby's attention. (AP Photo)
Prince Andrew and Queen Elizabeth II
Updated
Britain's Prince Andrew, son of Queen Elizabeth II, will celebrate his first birthday February 19. Friends of the Royal Family say the blue-eyed youngster is a placid, smiling infant, content to lie for long periods playing with his toes. He is shown last month during a ride through London on Jan. 16, 1961. (AP Photo)
Queen Elizabeth II and Prince Andrew
Updated
Queen Elizabeth II stands with her son, Prince Andrew, who waves from Buckingham Palace in London, on June 2, 1962, during fly past of Royal Air Force jet fighters. This followed the colorful pageant of trooping the color on the ninth anniversary of the queen's coronation and her official 36th birthday. The queen wears a tri-cornered hat and the uniform of the Coldstream Guards. Behind her stands the Duke of Kent. (AP Photo)
Prince Andrew 1964
Updated
Britain's Prince Andrew, who will be four years old on February 19, gazes at photographers at Liverpool street station in London, Feb. 3, 1964. The young Prince had just arrived from Sandringham in Norfolk with his mother, Queen Elizabeth II. (AP Photo/Laurence Harris)
Prince Andrew
Updated
British Prince Andrew, six-year-old second son of Queen Elizabeth II and Prince Philip wears western style deerskin jacket as he watches polo matches in Windsor Great Park at Windsor, England, on May 14, 1966. (AP Photo)
Prince Andrew 1968
Updated
Prince Andrew is shown as he arrived at King's Cross Station in London, Sept. 13, 1968. He looked smart in his grey suit and long trousers, grey shirt and red tie. Prince Andrew then left by car to Buckingham palace before going on to the Heatherdown boarding school at Ascot. (AP Photo/John Rider-Rider)
England Prince Andrew
Updated
Britain's Prince Andrew smiles as he leaves Heatherdown School, in Berkshire, on February 19, 1971, for his eleventh birthday. The Prince was driven from the school to Buckingham Palace to celebrate. (AP Photo/Kemp))
Queen Elizabeth II
Updated
Prince Andrew, right, talks with his parents, Queen Elizabeth II and Prince Phillip, during an outing on May 8, 1973 in the gardens of Windsor Castle, England. (AP Photo)
Prince Andrew
Updated
Prince Andrew the Queenâs 16-year-old son in London shown in July 1976, who is to spend two terms at a Canadian school. âThe prince has been involved in plan from the beginning, and is very happy at the prospectâ, said a Buckingham Palace spokesman. Prince Andrew, second in line to the throne, was in Canada when be accompanied the Queen and the Duke of Edinburgh to the Olympic Games in Montreal. It is intended he will be going to Lakefield College School, Ontario, in time for the beginning of the next term on January 5. (AP Photo)
Prince Andrew, Prince Charles
Updated
Prince Andrew, foreground, with his elder brother, Prince Charles, the heir to the British crown on Dec. 15, 1976. The occasion was Prince Andrewâs first visit to HMS Pronington of Wales in Royal Navy terms, was skipper off the coast of Scotland in November. Prince Andrew, 16, is second in lien to the throne after Prince Charles, and this makes him a young man the British will be watching with special interest. (AP Photo)
Duke of York
Updated
H.R.H. Prince Andrew, smiles in the Regency room of Buckingham Palace, London for the occasion of his 18th birthday, Feb. 19, 1978. The prince is the third child of Queen Elizabeth II and Prince Philip, and is second, after Prince Charles, in line of succession to the British throne. (AP Photo/Peter Grugeon)
Duke of York
Updated
H.R.H. Prince Andrew in his uniform, 1978. The prince is the third child of Queen Elizabeth II and Prince Philip, and is second, after Prince Charles, in line of succession to the British Throne. (AP Photo)
Queen Elizabeth II
Updated
Britain's Queen Elizabeth II takes a walk around the stalls at the Badminton Horse Trials on Saturday, April 21, 1979 in England, her 53rd birthday with her son Andrew (left). The Queen's daughter, Princess Anne was at the trials. No special celebration is planned for Her Majesty's birthday. (AP Photo)
Prince Andrew
Updated
Prince Andrew of Great Britain reported to his new commanding officer, Captain John Mackenzie in Pensacola, Fla., on Friday, Feb. 22, 1980. The Prince will spend three weeks aboard the HMS Hermes as a midshipman as part of his naval officer training. (AP Photo/Moore)
Prince Andrew
Updated
Britainâs Prince Andrew bites the stem of a red rose, after stepping ashore at Portsmouth, England on September 16, 1982, from the aircraft carrier HMS Invincible. A red rose was presented to each member of the Invincibleâs crew, as they left the vessel after her record 166 days at sea, which included action in the Falklands conflict. The 22-year-old prince, whose mother, Queen Elizabeth II welcomed him home, is a helicopter pilot aboard the vessel. (AP Photo/David Caulkin)
Prince Andrew
Updated
Prince Andrew after disembarking from the aircraft carrier Invincible when he arrived at Portsmouth on Thursday, April 28, 1983 after three months of exercises in the Caribbean and the Atlantic. After his leave, the prince will rejoin his squadron at Culdrose, Cornwall. Later he will go with his squadron to the Invincibleâs sister ship, Illustrious, for a NATO exercise. (AP Photo)
Prince Andrew
Updated
His Royal Highness Prince Andrew makes a close inspection of Cybil, a Jersey cow, at a 4-H livestock show in Sussex, N.B., on Tuesday, June 25, 1985. (AP Photo/Paul R. Benoit)
Ferguson
Updated
Prince Andrew and his bride-to-be, Sarah Ferguson, are shown in 1986. The couple will be married on Wednesday, July 23 at Westminster Abbey in London. Ferguson's engagement ring is an oval ruby surrounded by ten diamonds. (AP Photo)
Queen Elizabeth II and Prince Philip
Updated
On the balcony of Buckingham Palace, London on April 21, 1986, Queen Elizabeth II and her husband Prince Philip (right) are joined by one of their sons Prince Andrew and his fianc?e Sarah Fergusson on the occasion of the Queen's 60th birthday celebration. (AP Photo/Peter Kemp)
Sarah Ferguson
Updated
The newly-created Duke of York Prince Andrew and his bride Sarah Ferguson, the Duchess of York, ride in the 1802 State Landau carriage in a ceremonial procession to Londonâs Buckingham Palace after their marriage at Westminster Abbey, July 23, 1986. (AP Photo/Dave Caulkin)
Prince Andrew And Sarah Ferguson Honeymoon
Updated
The Duke and Duchess of York, Prince Andrew and Sarah Ferguson, at the rail of the royal yacht Britannia on arrival at Ponta Delgada, July 28, 1986 for an onboard dinner with local officials marking the end of their five-day honeymoon cruise through Portugalâs mid-Atlantic Azores archipelago. (AP Photo/Fernando Ricardo)
Prince Andrew, Sarah Ferguson
Updated
Duke And Duchess Of York
Updated
Britain's Duke and Duchess of York, Prince Andrew and Sarah Ferguson, with their new baby daughter in their arms as they leave the Portland Hospital in London, Aug. 12, 1988. The baby, the first for the royal couple, was born on Monday at night, and will be known as the Princess of York. (AP Photo)
ANDREW
Updated
The British Duke of York, Prince Andrew observes audio-visual presentation at "Mountain of Dreams" pavilion during his visit to the Aichi 2005 Expo in Nagakute, central Japan, Friday, April 22, 2005. Friday marks the United Kingdom of Great Britain National Day at the Aichi Expo. (AP Photo/Everete Kennedy Brown, Pool)
Prince Andrew
Updated
Prince Andrew, the Duke of York and International Business Liaison for the Queen of England, joins local politicians in opening a Fresh & Easy Neighborhood Market store Thursday, Feb. 7, 2008, in Compton, Calif. Tesco, which is headquartered in the UK, is the parent company. (AP Photos/Ric Francis)
BRITAIN GOLDEN WEDDING
Updated
Britain's Prince Andrew, the Duke of York, walks hand in hand with his two daughters Beatrice and Eugenie on their arrival at Greenwich Naval College, Thursday Nov. 20 1997 where Prince Charles was hosting a dinner for their parent's Golden Wedding celebrations. (AP Photo/Dave Caulkin)
Britain Royals
Updated
FILE - In this Tuesday, April 9, 2002 file photo members of Britain's Royal family follow the coffin of the Queen Mother , en route to her funeral in Westminster Abbey in London. They are from left: Prince Andrew, Prince Charles, Prince Philip, Princess Anne and Prince Edward. Queen Elizabeth II's husband, Prince Philip, will stop carrying out public engagements this fall, Buckingham Palace announced Thursday May 4, 2017. (AP Photo/Santiago Lyon, File)
Damon Hill, Prince Andrew
Updated
British former F1 World Champion Damon Hill, centre right, and Britain's Prince Andrew, left, after driving a lap, at the launch of the new GP Silverstone circuit, in Silverstone, England, Thursday, April 29, 2010. (AP Photo/Tom Hevezi)
Prince Andrew
Updated
Britain's Prince Andrew arrives in Canary Wharf to visrt the headquarters of the London CrossRail project, in London, Monday, March, 7, 2011. Prince Andrew will have to decide whether he can continue his role as a trade envoy amid a controversy about his links to a convicted pedophile, a British Cabinet minister said Monday. (AP Photo/Alastair Grant)
Hillary Clinton, Prince Andrew
Updated
Britain's Prince Andrew, right, talks to former U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, left, as she is presented with the Chatham House prize, a scroll signed by Queen Elizabeth II, Patron of the institute, during the Chatham House Prize award ceremony in central London, Friday, Oct. 11, 2013. Clinton was presented with the instituteâs annual award in recognition of her contribution to the significant improvement of international relations, according to the institution. (AP Photo/Lefteris Pitarakis)
APTOPIX Britain Royal Wedding
Updated
Britain's Prince Andrew, center, arrives with Princess Beatrice, right, and Princess Eugenie arrive for the wedding ceremony of Prince Harry and Meghan Markle at St. George's Chapel in Windsor Castle in Windsor, near London, England, Saturday, May 19, 2018. (Odd Anderson/pool photo via AP)
APTOPIX Britain Royals
Updated
From left, Britain's Prince Andrew, Queen Elizabeth, Meghan Duchess of Sussex, Prince Charles, Prince Harry, Kate Duchess of Cambridge and Prince William attend the annual Trooping the Colour Ceremony in London, Saturday, June 9, 2018.(AP Photo/Frank Augstein)
APTOPIX Britain Prince Philip Funeral
Updated
Britain's Prince Andrew inside St. Georgeâs Chapel during the funeral of his father, Prince Philip, at Windsor Castle, Windsor, England, Saturday April 17, 2021. Prince Philip died April 9 at the age of 99 after 73 years of marriage to Britain's Queen Elizabeth II. (Yui Mok/Pool via AP)
APTOPIX Britain Prince Philip Funeral
Updated
From left, Prince Andrew, Prince Edward, Prince Charles and Princess Anne arrive after walking in a procession behind the coffin of Prince Philip, with other members of the Royal family during the funeral of Britain's Prince Philip inside Windsor Castle in Windsor, England, Saturday, April 17, 2021. Prince Philip died April 9 at the age of 99 after 73 years of marriage to Britain's Queen Elizabeth II. (Chris Jackson/Pool via AP)



