Sara Bareilles is experiencing a โ€œpinch me momentโ€ times a million these days.

โ€œWaitress,โ€ her first-ever shot at composing for theater, has turned into stage gold, with four Tony Award nominations the year it opened on Broadway in 2016.

Itโ€™s still running on Broadway and on many nights, tickets are hard to come by.

โ€œMy hopes and dreams were all wrapped up into having one good, sort of fatted-calf year where weโ€™re not crawling across the finish line,โ€ she said during a phone call last week from New York, where she and her teenaged half-sister were shopping for prom dresses. โ€œOne year where we have a really solid show and the audience to come and see it.โ€

Well, one year is now three and the show is on the road including a stop next week in Tucson and next year in London.

โ€œIt is beyond my wildest imagination. I am so immensely grateful to the fans and the supporters of the show who have really embraced us and made us their own,โ€ Bareilles said. โ€œIt is just incredible.โ€

So how does a pop singer-songwriter (โ€œLove Song,โ€ โ€œBrave,โ€ โ€œGravityโ€) make that giant leap from deeply personal 3ยฝ-minute radio-friendly songs to composing the soundtrack for a 2ยฝ-hour stage show?

Look outward.

โ€œI think the biggest difference for me was having to write from a perspective that wasnโ€™t just telling my own story,โ€ she explained. โ€œIt was about finding my way into the mindset and the psychology of other characters.โ€

The process: โ€œI am really used to, as a songwriter, writing from the first-person perspective and in how it relates to my ideas of the world. I had to practice what I refer to as โ€˜radical empathyโ€™ and find my way into some of these other charactersโ€™ life experiences and imagining what they might be feeling. The biggest challenge was the characters that kind of lived further away from myself. I found my way into the character Jenna (the lead waitress) probably the most easily. But the abusive husband was a challenge, and the crotchety old man was a challenge. But I found over the course of writing for the show, I found a lot of love and caring for each of the characters. It was a really interesting experiment.โ€

The freedom to create: โ€œI really got so much beautiful freedom from my creative partners. It really was about a gut instinct and an initial reaction to the feeling and the tone of what music would serve which character. It evolved over time. I think certain characters sort of had their own personalities that came out in the music. For example, Ogie, who has a song called โ€˜Never Getting Rid of Me,โ€™ itโ€™s probably the most comic sounding song in the show and thatโ€™s because he is our most obvious comic relief in the show.โ€

Defining each characterโ€™s musical soul: โ€œEach character had these bold, broad strokes that kind of wanted to live in the music. So Becky, whoโ€™s this soulful, sassy waitress whoโ€™s kind of been around the block, I wanted to give her something that she could kind of sink her teeth into that had a lot of attitude. So it ended up being kind of a bluesy, rock song for her because it felt like it had a lot of power in a certain way. Jenna, her songs kind of lived in a place that felt soulful but also sort of pensive and introspective and I tried to give her musical themes that showed that she had this vivid imagination that was also constrained and protected in certain ways.โ€

Back to her music: Bareilles released the first single, the feminist homage โ€œArmor,โ€ off an album she will release early next year. She recorded it last summer in Los Angeles with legendary producer T Bone Burnett. โ€œItโ€™s been a minute โ€” itโ€™s been a long minute,โ€ she said of the five years since she released her last studio album. Of course, those five years were spent working on โ€œWaitress.โ€ The record, whose title is still a work in progress, is a hodgepodge of styles deeply influenced by her experience on โ€œWaitressโ€ and working with Burnett, the award-winning producer, whose work with movie soundtracks (โ€œO Brother, Where Art Thou?โ€ โ€œCold Mountain,โ€ โ€œWalk the Line,โ€ โ€œCrazy Heartโ€ and โ€œRaising Sandโ€), earned him seven of his 16 Grammys. โ€œI think what he brought more than anything โ€” because I think the album ends up sounding more eclectic โ€” he really values performance over perfection,โ€ she said.


Become a #ThisIsTucson member! Your contribution helps our team bring you stories that keep you connected to the community. Become a member today.

Contact reporter Cathalena E. Burch at cburch@tucson.com or 573-4642. On Twitter @Starburch