The Research Brief is a short take about interesting academic work.
The big idea
Asking customers to support a cause when they pay for stuff can heighten their anxiety. Contrary to the common belief that shoppers feel good about making donations at checkout, we have found that there is a downside to such charity campaigns.
For our study, co-authored with Alex Zablah, we researched how customers respond to donation requests made by cashiers or automated checkout kiosks.
We interviewed 60 shoppers, asking them to describe what they felt when they were asked to donate while ringing up their purchases at a variety of retailers based on their recollections of that interaction. About 40% of the words that these customers used expressed negative feelings associated with anxiety such as βpressured,β βannoyedβ and βconcerned about being judged.β Another 7% of the words conveyed other negative sentiments, including βguiltyβ or βbad.β The rest were neutral, such as βindifferent.β
Only about 20% of the words participants in these interviews used to describe their feelings were positive, such as βniceβ or βcompassionate.β
We also conducted a series of online experiments, in which a total of 970 people took part.
All of them were prompted to imagine that they were making a purchase, either at a fast-food drive-through or a grocery store. Half were also instructed to picture being asked to donate to a charity during checkout. The results were consistent with our findings from the interviews. Participants in the groups involving a charitable solicitation experienced more anxiety than those who only had to focus on making a purchase.
We also found evidence that this anxiety can be relieved when customers agree to donate, but only when the solicitation comes from a cashier, as opposed to an automated request made by a computer or self-service checkout machine.
Many trips to the supermarket include a small donation. Erik Isakson/Tetra Images via Getty Images
Why it matters
U.S. checkout charity campaigns raised US$605 million for assorted causes in 2020, with many donations totaling just a few cents.
Businesses that hold checkout charity campaigns collect their customersβ donations. They do not receive direct financial benefits, such as tax deductions, for raising money for local food banks or other causes.
Retailers and restaurants may expect customers to see them in a more positive light because of their engagement in charitable activity, and thereβs been some evidence to that effect.
But our study indicates that for many shoppers the results could be the opposite. For that reason, retailers and restaurants may want to weigh the risks before deciding to participate in these campaigns.
In particular, they may want to avoid asking shoppers to take part in checkout charity campaigns at self-checkout kiosks β where machines make the ask, instead of human beings.
What is not known
We didnβt look into why checkout charity might undercut a retailerβs popularity. Itβs possible that asking shoppers to donate in front of others makes them feel pressured. Or perhaps they may simply not want to chip in and feel annoyed when the cashier asks them.
We also did not assess whether customers know that businesses are not allowed to claim dollars donated by their customers as tax deductions.
___
The authors do not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organization that would benefit from this article, and have disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.
___
Watch Now: Tips for developing healthy work habits, and more videos to improve your life
Check out this advice for anyone wanting to work healthier, skin care myths you should stop following, and more videos to improve your life.
Lifehack's Sara Leandro, a certified health coach, recently offered some advice for anyone wanting to work healthier.
Buzz60βs Elizabeth Keatinge tells us about some skin care practices that you may want to skip.
Itβs very easy to spend a small fortune on groceries each week, but these six tips will help you save time and money.
Ordering coffee from your favorite cafΓ© can be a treat, but it's not the most budget-friendly option. Making a cup at home is a cheaper altern…
According to Greenpeace, only 9% of the world's plastic gets recycled. Instead, plastic waste continues to collect in our landfills and in our…
Everyone on social media has been talking about healing their skin barrier lately but not everyone knows what this is.
Here are some easy ways to save money on gas and energy in your apartment.
Etiquette experts agree, the grocery store has rules to be followed! Yair Ben-Dor has more.
Lounging around the hotel is nice, but have you considered biking around? Yair Ben-Dor has more.
