PHOENIX β Itβs promoted as a measure to ensure that no future governor shuts down religious services during an emergency.
But some legislators worry that the actual wording of the legislation would give churches and other religious organizations not only special privileges to operate during pandemics and other situations but potentially immunize them from lawsuits over child abuse.
HB 2648 would spell out in statute that religious services βare declared an essential service and are deemed necessary and vital to the health and welfare of the public.β The bill already has cleared the House and now awaits a Senate floor vote.
Rep. Ben Toma, R-Peoria, who is sponsoring the measure, said itβs simply designed to put churches on even footing with other businesses.
βThe spirit of the bill is essentially to say that if Costco and Walmart and any other private business is allowed to be open during a pandemic, then so should religious organizations,β he said.
What it also would allow a religious organization to sue the state to not only get a declaration that it is entitled to continue to operate but also for monetary damages. Toma said thatβs appropriate.
βIf they are discriminated against, there should be financial consequences on any governments that infringe on their rights,β he said.
But the verbiage in the bill is raising questions about whether this is about more than giving churches the equal opportunity to stay open.
It starts with language designed to provide protection against βdiscriminatory actionβ by the government. Specifically the concern is over what that includes.
For example, it would bar state government from causing βany tax, penalty or payment to be assessed against a religions organization.β And it would prohibit imposition of any βmonetary fine, fee, civil or criminal penalty, damages award or injunction against a religious organization.
That language alarmed Rep. Melody Hernandez, D-Tempe.
βThere is currently a long-term, worldwide scandal about sexual abuse of children in religious organizations,β she said.
βAnd this has resulted in many fines, fees, penalties and criminal sanctions against religious organizations,β Hernandez continued. βAnd I am incredibly concerned that this billβs prohibition would deny children victims any recompense for their abuse.β
Sen. Martin Quezada, D-Glendale, also said this appears to be about far more than letting congregations meet during a pandemic.
βThe expansive breadth of this bill is astonishing,β he said. Itβs βcompletely unnecessary,β and not just because Gov. Doug Ducey has specifically exempted religious services from any restrictions in his emergency declaration.
Quezada cited a ruling last month by the U.S. Supreme Court which overturned a California ban on indoor church services as a method to fight the pandemic.
The court, however, did uphold attendance limits based on the size of the facility. And the justices said that, given the way the COVID-19 virus spreads, state could prohibit singing and chanting during services.
Tomaβs bill would allow the state to require religious organizations to comply with βneutral health, safety or occupancy requirementsβ as long as they are apply to other organizations also also provide essential services. But it does say that that the state cannot impose βa substantial burden on a religious serviceβ absent showing it is βessential to further a compelling governmental interest and is the least restrictive means of furthering that compelling governmental interest.β
Sen. J.D. Mesnard R-Chandler, acknowledged that the measure does deal more than just what happens during a declared emergency. But he said he does not read the bill as broadly as some of the foes.
βThere is no immunity in this bill except for one thing: immunity from discrimination,β he said. Mesnard said it does not immunize religious organizations to go out and break any law.
Sen. Jamescita Peshlakai, D-Window Rock, openly questioned the need to cater to the church.
Peshlakai said she understands the stated goal is to protect religion in government. But she said that hardly appears necessary.
βI see nothing but the protection of the church in this state and in this country,β she said. By contrast, Peshlakai said Native Americans were not granted freedom of religion until President Jimmy Carter signed the American Indian Religious Freedom Act in 1978, overruling laws that had rendered some religions and sacred ceremonies illegal.
Yet all along, other non-Native American religions were given the freedom βto hurt people,β relating how her grandfather, in the name of converting Native Americans to Christianity, was forced to go to an Indian school.
βSo I am very wary of giving that much immunity and that lack of responsibility to these religious essential services,β Peshlakai said.
Get to know your Arizona lawmakers
District 2
UpdatedSenator Rosanna Gabaldon (D)
Committee Assignments: Commerce; Health and Human Services; Transportation and Technology
Phone: 602-926-3424
Email: RGABALDON@azleg.gov
District 2
UpdatedRep. Andrea Dalessandro (D)
Committee Assignments: Land, Agriculture and Rural Affairs; Natural Resources, Energy and Water
Phone: 602-926-5342
Email: ADALESSANDRO@azleg.gov
District 2
UpdatedRep. Daniel Hernandez Jr. (D)
Committee Assignments: Education; Military Affairs and Public Safety
Phone: 602-926-4840
Email: DHERNANDEZ@azleg.gov
2020 Candidate Chats: AZ Legislative District 2
UpdatedDistrict 3
UpdatedSenator Sally Ann Gonzales (D)
Committee Assignments: Education; Health and Human Services
Phone: 602-926-3278
Email: SGONZALES@azleg.gov
District 3
UpdatedAndres Cano (D)
Committee Assignments: Natural Resources, Energy & Water; Ways and Means
Phone: 602-926-3027
Email: ACANO@azleg.gov
District 3
UpdatedAlma Hernandez (D)
Committee Assignments: Criminal Justice Reform; Health and Human Services
Phone: 602-926-3136
Email: AHERNANDEZ@azleg.gov
District 9
UpdatedSenator Victoria Steele (D) (Minority Whip)
Committee Assignments: Natural Resources, Energy and Water; Transportation and Technology
Phone: 602-926-5683
Email: VSTEELE@azleg.gov
District 9
UpdatedRep. Randall Friese (D)
Committee Assignments: Appropriations; Health and Human Services
Phone: 602-926-3138
Email: RFRIESE@azleg.gov
District 9
UpdatedRep. Pamela Powers Hannley
Committee Assignments: Commerce; Ways and Means
Phone: 602-926-4848
Email: PPOWERSHANNLEY@azleg.gov
2020 Candidate Chats: AZ Legislative District 9
UpdatedDistrict 10 Kristen Engel
UpdatedSenator Kirsten Engel (D)
Committee Assignments: Finance; Judiciary; National Resources, Energy and Water
Phone: 602-926-5178
Email: KENGEL@azleg.gov
District 10 Domingo DeGrazia
UpdatedRep. Domingo DeGrazia (D) (Minority Whip)
Committee Assignments: Judiciary; Rules
Phone: 602-926-3153
Email: DDEGRAZIA@azleg.gov
District 10 Stephanie Stahl Hamilton
UpdatedRep. Stephanie Stahl Hamilton (D)
Committee Assignments: Government and Elections; Natural Resources, Energy and Water
Phone: 602-926-3279
Email: SSTAHLHAMILTON@azleg.gov
2020 Candidate Chats: AZ Legislative District 10
UpdatedDistrict 11
UpdatedSenator Vince Leach (R) (President Pro Tempore)
Committee Assignments: Appropriations; Finance; Judiciary; Rules
Phone: 602-926-3106
Email: VLEACH@azleg.gov
District 11
UpdatedRep. Mark Finchem (R)
Committee Assignments: Judiciary; Military Affairs and Public Safety; Natural Resources, Energy and Water
Phone: 602-926-3122
Email: MFINCHEM@azleg.gov
District 11
UpdatedRep. Bret Roberts (R)
Committee Assignments: Criminal Justice Reform; Education; Military Affairs and Public Safety
Phone: 602-926-3158
Email: BROBERTS@azleg.gov
2020 Candidate Chats: AZ Legislative District 11
UpdatedDistrict 14
UpdatedSenator David Gowan (R)
Committee Assignments: Appropriations; Natural Resources, Energy and Water
Phone: 602-926-5154
Email: DGOWAN@azleg.gov
District 14
UpdatedRep. Gail Griffin (R)
Committee Assignments: Natural Resources, Energy and Water; Land, Agriculture and Rural Affairs
Phone: 602-926-5895
Email: GGRIFFIN@azleg.gov
District 14
UpdatedRep. Becky A. Nutt (R)
Committee Assignments: Rules; Appropriations; Commerce
Phone: 602-926-4852
Email: BNUTT@azleg.gov