The Arizona Daily Star won 32 journalism awards in the Arizona Newspapers Association’s 2019 contest, including first place in general excellence in the largest-newspapers category.
Perla Trevizo was named Arizona Journalist of the Year for her work as the Star’s border and immigration reporter, and the Star’s Kelly Presnell was honored as Arizona Photographer of the Year for the second year in a row.
The awards were announced Sept. 28, with Newspaper of the Year honors — calculated from awards won in advertising as well as journalism categories — going to the Navajo Times for non-daily and the Herald/Review for daily.
Traffic on 6th street speeds by the Goddess of Agave mural on the old Tucson Warehouse & Transfer Co., and the current home of Benjamin Supply, in this award-winning photo from Star photographer Kelly Presnell.
The Star’s other honors in the ANA’s 2019 Better Newspapers Contest were:
First places, staff:
Reporting and newswriting excellence.
Page design excellence.
Editorial page excellence.
Supplement or magazine.
Newspaper website (Tucson.com).
First places, individuals:
Best team, sport or sports beat coverage, Norma Gonzalez (Pima football).
Best sports column, Greg Hansen (“Arizona superfan”).
Best column, analysis or commentary: David Fitzsimmons (“Monastery-turned-sanctuary truly extraordinary”).
Best column, feature or criticism, David Fitzsimmons (“Y.O.T.O. backs youths’ dreams, despite homelessness”).
Best multimedia storytelling, Perla Trevizo (“Passports to the American Dream,” reported from Guatemala).
Best feature photograph, Mike Christy (“Cloud walk”).
Best feature photo layout or photo story, Kelly Presnell (“New border dynamic presents quandary no wall can solve”).
Second places, individuals:
Best headline, Dave Ord (assorted headlines).
Best news story, Caitlin Schmidt (“4 suspect ID’d here after tests on shelved rape kits.”)
Best team, sport or sports beat coverage, Caitlin Schmidt (“Athletes investigated at the UA”).
Enterprise reporting, Emily Bregel (“Evictions: No roof, no relief”).
Best column, analysis or commentary, Tim Steller (“The Chomsky outrage”).
Best column, feature or criticism, Greg Hansen (“A miracle and a young man named Brian saved my son’s life”).
Online coverage of breaking news, Caitlin Schmidt and Shaq Davis (“Local man indicted in killing of Tucson girls”).
Best news photograph, Kelly Presnell (“Vigil for murdered student”).
Best sports photograph, Kelly Presnell (“Looming clouds”).
Best feature photograph, Mamta Popat (“Late snow”).
Third places, individuals:
Best news story, Caitlin Schmidt and Shaq Davis (“Inmate, 36, indicted in deaths of two girls”).
Best feature story, Perla Trevizo (with Fernanda Echavarri of Latino USA), (“30 days to be a family”).
Best column, analysis or commentary, Sarah Garrecht Gassen (“Growing Pima County”).
Best column, feature or criticism, David Fitzsimmons (“What good cops do”).
Best multimedia storytelling, Perla Trevizo (“Shifting trends: How do you secure the border when migrants are just turning themselves in?”).
Best sports photograph, Kelly Presnell (“Timeout!”).
Best feature photograph, Mamta Popat (“Brain surprise”).
Advertising contest
Also, in the Arizona Newspapers Association’s 2019 Excellence in Advertising Contest, the Star received four awards including first place in general excellence; first place in most effective use of small space, Alexis Walters; first place for best animated online ad, Jay Walsh; and third place for best color ad, Alexis Walters.
Star's Kelly Presnell named Arizona Photographer of the Year
Kelly Presnell, Photographer of the Year portfolio
Updated
Dancers watch for the wings, watching their castmates and waiting their cue to take the stage during a dress rehearsal for the Tucson Regional Ballet's production of Southwest Nutcracker at the TCC Music Hall, Wednesday, December 12, 2018, Tucson, Ariz.
Goddess of Agave mural
Updated
Traffic on Sixth Street speeds by the Goddess of Agave mural on the old Tucson Warehouse & Transfer Co., and the current home of Benjamin Supply, at Seventh Ave., Friday, March 22, 2019, Tucson, Ariz.
Kelly Presnell, Photographer of the Year portfolio
Updated
Kyle Eaton gets pinned by his ride Muley Madness after getting tossed in the bull riding completion on the opening day of the 94th Annual Fiesta de los Vaqueros Tucson Rodeo, Saturday, February 16, 2019, Tucson, Ariz.
Kelly Presnell, Photographer of the Year portfolio
Updated
Mitch Pollock tests the stirrups of his saddle as the prepares for the saddle bronc event on the second day of competition the 94th Annual Fiesta de los Vaqueros Tucson Rodeo, Snday, February 16, 2019, Tucson, Ariz.
Kelly Presnell, Photographer of the Year portfolio
Updated
Emily Watkins de Jong, left, and Amy Floyd hold each other during a vigil for their classmate Genevieve Comeau at the University of Arizona, Thursday, March 14, 2019, Tucson, Ariz. Comeau, the victim of murder/suicide on March 5, 2019, was a PhD candidate at the U of A.
Kelly Presnell, Photographer of the Year portfolio
Updated
Tucson Fire Department personnel rescue musical instruments from an adjoining unit while working on structure fire at 1319 S. 6th Ave., Wednesday, December 5, 2018, Tucson, Ariz. Fire units were dispatched at 2:15 p.m. and had the fire under control at around 2:50. Several residences and apartments retrofitted into the structure were involved in the fire, smoke or water damage.
Kelly Presnell, Photographer of the Year portfolio
Updated
Arizona guard Aari McDonald (2) yells for a timeout as Northwestern players converge on her in a scramble for a loose ball in the championship game of the WNIT at McKale Center, Saturday, April 6, 2019, Tucson, Ariz.
Kelly Presnell, Photographer of the Year portfolio
Updated
Sunset behind the utility towers southeast of the city near Houghton and I-10, Saturday, June 30, 2018, Tucson, Ariz.
Kelly Presnell, Photographer of the Year portfolio
Updated
Cienega's Diego Rubi (2) holds on for dear life to drag down Marana's Xoeius Ratliffe (21) for a five yard loss helping blunt a Tiger comeback late in the fourth quarter of their game at Cienega High School, Friday, April 12, 2018, Tucson, Ariz.
Kelly Presnell, Photographer of the Year portfolio
Updated
Eleven-month old Denilison Agustin stands with his mother, Marleen Aguilon, with an ankle tracer bracelet, in the Yuma Refugee Ministry shelter, Saturday, July 27, 2018, Yuma, Ariz.
Kelly Presnell, Photographer of the Year portfolio
Updated
A crucifix is adorned by rosaries and icons from migrants at the Casa del Migrante la Divina Providencia, Thursday, July 26, 2018, San Luis Rio Colorado, Sonora.
Kelly Presnell, Photographer of the Year portfolio
Updated
Several refugees from Central America and Mexico talk with Customs and Border Protection officers, trying to get admitted into the US for asylum interviews at the pedestrian entrance of the San Luis Port of Entry, Thursday, July 26, 2018, San Luis Rio Colorado, Sonora.
Kelly Presnell, Photographer of the Year portfolio
Updated
Maureen Aguilon, bottom, and her son Denilison Agustin, Catarina Jacinto and her daughter Petrona Perez lay down for post lunch nap at the Yuma Refugee Ministry's shelter, Saturday, July 27, 2018, Yuma, Ariz.
Kelly Presnell, Photographer of the Year portfolio
Updated
Melani Gayana plays with the toys she's carefully collected at the Yuma Refugee Ministry's one-room shelter, Saturday, July 27, 2018, Yuma, Ariz.
Kelly Presnell, Photographer of the Year portfolio
Updated
Alicia Chilel, her son Oscar, from Central American and Reynaldo Ruiz, brother Jason, mother Maria and sister Estrella wait in the Target parking lot for the bus to take them east after being released by ICE, Saturday, July 27, 2018, Yuma, Ariz.
Kelly Presnell, Photographer of the Year portfolio
Updated
Yuma Refugee Ministry volunteer Fernie Quiroz hugs Anna Pascual and her daughter Kimberly as they prepare to board a bus for the east coast, two of several Central American immigrants released by ICE, Saturday, July 27, 2018, Yuma, Ariz.

