Trump's mixed messages on Iran: 'Winding down' the war but adding more troops

President Donald Trump frequently contradicts himself, sometimes in the same speech, social media post or even sentence. In the past 24 hours, he sent a torrent of mixed signals about the Iran war that raise more questions about the direction of the conflict and his administration's strategy.

On Friday alone, Trump said he was considering winding down the war, his administration confirmed it was sending more troops to the Middle East and the United States lifted sanctions on some Iranian oil for the first time in decades — relieving some of the pressure that Washington traditionally used as leverage.

He issued another contradictory statement Saturday evening, threatening to escalate the conflict by targeting Iran's power plants unless the country lets oil shipments pass through the Strait of Hormuz.

The confusing combination of actions deepens a sense among Trump's critics that there is no clear, long-term strategy for the war the U.S. and Israel launched against Iran.

'Winding down' the war

After another rough day in the financial markets, Trump said Friday afternoon on social media: "We are getting very close to meeting our objectives as we consider winding down our great Military efforts in the Middle East."

He contended the U.S. adequately degraded Iranian naval, missile and industrial capacity and prevented Tehran from acquiring a nuclear weapon.

The Republican president then suggested the U.S. could pull out of the conflict without stabilizing the Strait of Hormuz, through which about one-fifth of the world's oil supply travels. The strait was ravaged by Iranian missile, drone and mine attacks during the war.

"The Hormuz Strait will have to be guarded and policed, as necessary, by other Nations who use it — The United States does not!" Trump wrote. But, in another contradiction, he said the U.S. would help if asked.

While oil that traverses the strait usually is bound for Asia and other places rather than North America, the chaos still affects the U.S. Oil is bought and sold globally, so a shortage in oil for Asian countries leads to bidding up prices on oil sold to companies in America, too.

That fact, coupled with an Israeli strike on Iran's gas fields and an Iranian retaliation that crippled a major terminal to ship liquefied natural gas from Qatar, helped tank U.S. equity markets Friday. There also was a sharp increase in U.S. fuel prices.

More US military might to the Middle East

Even as Trump said the U.S. was close to winding down the war, the administration announced it sent three more warships to the Middle East with about 2,500 additional Marines. It was the second time in the week that the administration said it was deploying more forces to the conflict. The military says about 50,000 support the war effort.

Trump ruled out sending in ground troops, though his administration hinted at a possible deployment of special forces or similar units.

Back to homepage

Subscriber Login

Keep reading with a digital access subscription.

Subscribe now

The Marines being sent to the region are an expeditionary unit designed for quick amphibious landings, but their deployment does not mean a ground invasion is certain. Analysts have suggested it may require the presence of U.S. forces on the ground to ultimately secure the strait.

The surge in troops came just a day after news emerged that the Pentagon was seeking an additional $200 billion from Congress to fund the war. That extraordinarily high number does not suggest that the war was being wound down.

Sanctions on Iranian oil sales

The administration said it would lift sanctions on the sale of Iranian oil, provided it was already at sea as of Friday to help lower skyrocketing energy prices by allowing freer sale of oil that Iran let pass through the strait. It also extends a financial lifeline to the Iranian government that Trump is targeting.

His administration tried other methods to lower oil prices. It tapped the U.S. strategic petroleum reserve and lifted sanctions on some Russian oil. Yet analysts say oil prices are likely to remain high for months regardless of the next steps in the war.

Economy

US drivers see gas prices jump to highest level since 2023 as Iran war drags on

• WYATTE GRANTHAM-PHILIPS Associated Press

The Iranian oil eventually would have reached another country, but now the U.S. and its allies can bid on it as well, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent wrote on social media.

"At present, sanctioned Iranian oil is being hoarded by China on the cheap," he wrote. "By temporarily unlocking this existing supply for the world, the United States will quickly bring approximately 140 million barrels of oil to global markets, expanding the amount of worldwide energy and helping to relieve the temporary pressures on supply caused by Iran."

While 140 million barrels may seem like a lot, that is only a couple of days' worth of oil on the global market.

Government-politics

Iran war underscores risks of Trump's relentless focus on oil

• MATTHEW DALY Associated Press

Patrick De Haan, head of petroleum analysis at GasBuddy, a U.S. fuel-tracking service, said he does not expect the temporary suspension to have a major effect on gas prices. The de facto closure of the strait has a much greater effect, he said. "Prices will likely still continue to rise so long as the Strait remains silent," he noted.

The contradictions in the position were obvious in Bessent's post announcing the move, which labeled Iran "the head of the snake for global terrorism." He said the administration would take steps to prevent Tehran from cashing in on the sales, but it was unclear how that would be done.

Even among some Republicans, the contradictions triggered rare public skepticism.

"Bombing Iran with one hand and buying Iran oil with the other," Rep. Nancy Mace of South Carolina posted Saturday on social media.

Columnists

Is modern life eroding our willingness to sacrifice for something greater? | The Ethical Life podcast

• Scott Rada

Photos from the Mideast in the 4th week of the Iran war