Tom Margenau

My inbox has been inundated with emails from worried senior citizens who tell me they have heard that President Trump will end Social Security if he is reelected and that the trust funds will dry up in 2023 and all Social Security checks will stop going out.

I can’t imagine the president has plans to end Social Security. But it doesn’t help that he puts his famous foot in his famous mouth and says things that people can interpret to mean exactly that. Trump recently made some rather unfortunate remarks about the Social Security payroll tax that has caused all the uproar. And his aides have been scrambling to come up with excuses and clarifications.

On Aug. 8, the president told a gathering of supporters, “If I’m victorious on Nov. 3 I plan to make permanent cuts to the (Social Security) payroll tax.”

The government publicly released the report of the Warren Commission, which concluded that Lee Harvey Oswald had acted alone in assassinating President John F. Kennedy, and more events that happened on this day in history.

Because our Social Security system, like almost every other social insurance system in the world, operates on a “pay-as-you-go” basis, meaning that the income derived from today’s tax collections is used to fund tomorrow’s Social Security benefits, any such major cuts to the Social Security tax would have to result in major cuts to Social Security benefits.

The very next day, White House economic adviser Larry Kudlow told reporters that the president misspoke.

But then, just a couple of days later, on Aug. 12, Trump told another group this: “We’ll be terminating the (Social Security) payroll tax after I, hopefully, get elected. We’ll be terminating the payroll tax, so that will mean anywhere from $5,000 to even more per family, and also great for businesses and great for jobs.”

Well, this led to a firestorm of controversy. At the request of some Democratic senators, the Social Security Administration’s chief actuary issued a letter stating that if the payroll tax were terminated on Jan. 1, 2021, the disability trust fund would be permanently depleted in about the middle of calendar year 2021 with no ability to pay disability benefits after that. And the actuaries further estimated the retirement and survivors trust fund would become permanently depleted by the middle of calendar year 2023, with no ability to pay retirement and survivor benefits after that.

Once again, Trump’s advisers had to scramble to explain what he supposedly meant to say. When asked at a press conference if the president really intended to end the Social Security payroll tax, White House Press Secretary Kayleigh McEnany told reporters he did not. She clarified, “What he was meaning yesterday is that he wants permanent forgiveness of the deferral.”

I can hear many of you saying, “Huh, what does that mean?” So, now let me clarify the clarification for the readers of this column.

In early August, as one part of an economic stimulus plan, Trump issued a memo stipulating that people who make less than $8,000 per month would not have Social Security taxes deducted from their paychecks.

That tax break began on Sept. 1 and will end on Dec. 31. And it is considered a tax “deferral.” In other words, the tax payments would be “deferred” to a later date — meaning they would have to be paid back at some point. (The president does not have the authority to change or eliminate the Social Security payroll tax, but he can order a deferral of the payment of those taxes.)

However, in the same memorandum, the president told his Treasury secretary that he wanted him to “explore avenues, including legislation, to eliminate the obligation to pay the taxes deferred.”

So, according to his economic advisers and other aides, when Trump tells people he plans to end the payroll tax, what he really means to say is he plans to end the obligation that people making less than $8,000 per month would have to eventually pay the deferred Social Security tax payments.

But then, at a subsequent press conference, Trump told reporters: “If I’m victorious on Nov. 3, I plan to forgive these taxes and make permanent cuts to the payroll tax. So, I’m going to make them all permanent.”

So, you tell me. Is Trump just being Trump and shooting off his mouth and saying things he really doesn’t mean? Or does he indeed have plans to ask Congress to either cut or eliminate Social Security payroll taxes. If the latter, then how can he justify another statement he made: “We’re not going to touch Social Security. I said from day one that we’re going to protect Social Security and we’re going to protect our people.” With all due respect, Mr. President, you can’t have it both ways.

And now let me add a dose of sanity to any discussion of the future of Social Security.

I will bet my next dozen Social Security checks that no matter who wins the upcoming presidential election, either President Trump or President Joe Biden will appoint some kind of bipartisan commission on Social Security reform.

The last time that happened was in 1982, following Ronald Reagan’s election as president. At the time, Social Security was facing an economic crunch not too dissimilar to the one that plagues the system today. The commission, headed by Alan Greenspan, came up with a mix of reforms that included some benefit cuts and some tax increases. For example, the retirement age was raised from 65 to 67. And the schedule for some already planned payroll tax increases was moved up a few years. (Those are just two of about a couple dozen changes the commission recommended.)

And those reforms worked. Social Security has been running in the black for the last 40 years. But now we face the baby boomer crunch. For about the last five years, about 10,000 of us have been signing up for Social Security every single day. And that trend is going to continue for the next 15 years.

And the solution to that demographic challenge is not a payroll tax cut (unless it is accompanied by massive and immediate benefit cuts). The solution will likely involve another mix of long-range benefit cuts and payroll tax increases. I will bet the retirement age will be bumped up to 68 or even 70 (not for near term retirees but for younger people, giving them time to plan).

And I’m guessing either the payroll tax will be slightly increased or the wage base (the amount subject to Social Security tax) will go up significantly.

And these will be just two of a package of reforms that will keep the Social Security system solvent for generations to come — no matter who is sitting in the White House.

10 insights on today's news that will make you smarter tomorrow

Stay in the know! Browse through opinions and analysis on today's hottest topics.

Spotlight AP
  • Updated

Crystals are part of a larger tradition of metaphysical religions that have a long history in the U.S.

Spotlight AP
  • Updated

A severe shortage of tampons alongside sharp price increases have sparked concerns that lower-income women may have difficulty accessing menstrual products.

Spotlight
  • Updated

A climate scientist looks at what works to fight climate change and some popular ideas that aren’t as cheap or effective as people hope.

Spotlight

Here's a look at a grand jury's major role in criminal justice and why prosecutors are using them to investigate efforts to overturn the 2020 election.

Spotlight

Rising concern about possible environmental damage from the active ingredients in sunscreens could have ripple effects on public health if it causes people to use less of them.

Spotlight
  • Updated

The attack on Salman Rushdie promptly led to speculation on whether the attacker had been influenced by the 1989 fatwa against the author. A scholar explains what a fatwa is — and isn’t.

Spotlight
  • Updated

Energy modeling software provides insight into whether letting your AC relax while you’re gone all day will save you energy — and money.

Spotlight

Holocaust scholars once relied on documents and survivor testimonies to reconstruct history. Now, they’re turning to wordless witnesses to learn more: long-lost pictures found in attics and archives.

Spotlight

There are benefits to taking college classes in the metaverse, but there are also potential problems.

Spotlight
  • Updated

Natural gas has been marketed for decades as a clean fuel, but a growing body of research shows that gas stoves can contribute significantly to indoor air pollution, as well as climate change.

Spotlight
  • Updated

Paying for the stuff you want with currency is way easier than relying on chairs you made or chickens you raised.

Spotlight
  • Updated

Understanding why people underpredict expenses could help them budget more accurately — and even encourage them to save more money.

Spotlight
  • Updated

Artificial intelligence can spot differences in images from before and after a storm over wide areas in almost real time. It showed Hurricane Ian’s vast damage in Florida.

Spotlight

Buddhists believe that bodhisattvas reside in heavenly realms but can also appear on Earth disguised as humans, animals or other types of beings.

Spotlight
  • Updated

There hasn’t been a new form of male birth control since the 1980s. More contraception options for all partners could help reduce the rate of unintended pregnancies.

Spotlight
  • Updated

Rapid tests can be an incredibly useful tool for early detection of COVID-19. Unfortunately, they sometimes leave people with more questions than answers.

Spotlight
  • Updated

College can be a time to interact with people with different worldviews, but meaningful exchanges often require intent.

Spotlight
  • Updated

Going out of your way to get grossed out might seem like a contradiction of human nature. But it serves a strong evolutionary purpose.

Spotlight

Have you visited Yew Nork? Does your stummy ache? What dog of bag food will we get? A psycholinguist explains what’s really going on when people misspeak.

Spotlight

For every headline about pickleball’s miraculous growth you can also find stories about conflicts and infighting among various leagues and governing bodies, as well as between pickleballers and tennis players.

Spotlight
  • Updated

Respiratory viruses are hitting young children and infants particularly hard this fall and winter season, and experts don’t yet know exactly why.

Spotlight
  • Updated

A finance expert explains why President Biden’s student loan forgiveness program got blocked — and what’s next for student loan borrowers in search of relief.

Spotlight
  • Updated

FTX founder Sam Bankman-Fried, his on-and-off girlfriend and others involved in the failed company were reportedly in a polycule together.

Spotlight
  • Updated

Research shows storms that might have caused minimal damage a few decades ago are becoming stronger and more destructive as the planet warms.

Spotlight
  • Updated

Researchers know pregnant moms’ brains change in ways that seem to help with caring for a baby. Now they've ID'd changes in new dads’ brains too.

Spotlight
  • Updated

How can you best find a balance during the holidays so that you are fulfilled instead of frazzled? Perhaps you should take a few cultural cues from the Danes.

Spotlight
  • Updated

Toilets eject aerosol droplets that may carry disease-causing pathogens. Learning how the particles move could help cut exposure in public restrooms.

Spotlight

The death of a pet can be a deeply painful experience. But acknowledging the way pet grief is different can help people find consolation.

Spotlight
  • Updated

How is it possible to spend so much time with your parents and grandparents and not really know them? If you skirt the small talk and dig a little deeper, you’ll be surprised at what you might learn.

Spotlight
  • Updated

Long-term consumption of food allergens may lead to behavioral and mood changes, including depression, anxiety and ADHD.

Spotlight
  • Updated

The dead of winter, when the longest night of the year takes place, is also a time of renewal. Here's why the winter solstice is worth celebrating.

Spotlight
  • Updated

Mindfulness can teach us to be more present — not just for ourselves, but also for our colleagues, friends and loved ones.

Spotlight
  • Updated

Do you think that creativity is an innate gift? Think again. New research highlights how anyone can train their creative muscles by rethinking the anxiety, frustration and anger they encounter in daily life.

Spotlight
  • Updated

Childbearing goals have remained remarkably consistent over the decades. What has changed is when people start their families and how many kids they end up having.

Spotlight
  • Updated

Cold weather brings itchy, irritated, dry and scaly skin. Although most conditions aren’t dangerous, they can be painful and frustrating to deal with. 

Spotlight
  • Updated

While excess weight arises from a complex interplay of genes, environment, diet and activity, new research finds Americans hold parents responsible for excess weight in their kids.

Spotlight

If Easter is associated with celebration and triumphal joy for Christians, Lent is more a season of soul-searching and spiritual discipline. Here are some articles exploring the history and significance of Ash Wednesday and Lent.

Spotlight
  • Updated

The mental health of teenagers has grown far worse over the last decade. But a new report shows that, compared with boys, teen girls are disproportionately experiencing sadness and hopelessness.

High-quality bus service is the fastest route to rapid, comprehensive public transit in the United States. This country was once a leader in bus transit, and with adequate funding, it could be again.

Spotlight

Smartphone cameras tend to be more advanced than their clunky, point-and-shoot predecessors. But the allure of cameras from the early 2000s reflects a broader search for meaning.


Become a #ThisIsTucson member! Your contribution helps our team bring you stories that keep you connected to the community. Become a member today.

If you have a Social Security question, Tom Margenau has the answer. Contact him at thomas.margenau@comcast.net.